Monday, August 5, 2019

Honoring the Sacred


It is not about science versus what is sacred.
Rick Bennett MS, PhD
Applied Life Sciences, LLC
Kukuiopae, Hawai‘i
Way back in 1973, I began my graduate school education to become a scientist. By 1974 I was collecting data and analyzing it. Those were my first days being scientific. Then in 1976, the University of California awarded me its highest degree. I was but 26 years old. I had learned a new language, the language of science. Even in those formative years, my ethic directed me to use this new tool only for good.
It disturbs me no end; the hear the media and various "leaders" cast science as some exalted religion that by definition, is intrinsically right and true. They use being scientific to mean, all things scientific are inherently better than any other. This is an ignorant abuse of the term.
Science is not a religion, a philosophy, or a set of fixed ideologies. Science is a method to investigate the natural world systematically. Like any other tool in the hands of people, it is subject to benign misinterpretation and vulnerable to selfish abuse and human atrocities. In modern history, we have witnessed science used for horrific purposes. One most notable abuse occurred on Moloka‘i at Kalaupapa. The medical doctor M. Mouritz intentionally infected local people with the leprosy agent to study the disease.[1] Similarly, African American men were purposefully infected with Syphilis in 1932 and followed up until 1972, when a newspaper story exposed the doctors.[2] The US military and the CIA conducted many experiments on humans without regard for their rights or well-being. The US military sprayed bacteria on San Francisco and other cities as a bio-weapons test in 1950. They believed bacteria were harmless; however, some people got serious infections and died.[3] The military conducted this experiment in the name of science. The list of horrific experiments could go on and on. Slightly less lethal but certainly not benign is the significant number of scientific studies, conducted on new drugs. The data was falsified to make the drugs appear safe and effective when they were not.[4] Let's suffice it to say science is a double-edged sword, and its effects are all determined by the person wielding it.
As a teenager, I had the great fortune for the opportunity to travel into many wilderness areas of California. I vividly recall standing at the base of Mt. Whitney as the setting sun cast ethereal shadows across its face. I felt in the presence of the Creator.
My family spent many weekends in the deserts in the south of California. There were times when the vast majesty of a verdant wildflower-filled valley or the pastel hues of the Chocolate Mountains would evoke a sense of awe and great reverence. We were not a religious family, but these experiences taught me the word sacred. That understanding has guided me as a person and a scientist all my life. It has evoked great respect and compassion for beliefs of indigenous peoples of the world. Not too many years ago, a tribal elder took me aside and told me; it is time native people teach the westerners how to live in the world. I told him given the wrath we have wrought on the planet; we do need to learn.
From time to time, believing in the sacred put me at odds with my scientist friends. I recall a rousing conversation I had with an overzealous scientist colleague. I was attempting to explain my belief in nature as a sacred thing. He retorted, there is no such attribute to nature. It cannot be measured; therefore, it does not exist. This belief about measuring among scientists is not unique. I felt unable to defend my belief, and then it hit me. I retorted I am sure you love your wife and family. Of course, he snapped. Well then, I said, how do you measure love?
The first time I visited Mauna Kea, I was awestruck, just like in my youth. It is a feeling, a belief that cannot fully be explained and certainly not measurable. The sunset photo I have reminds me of that moment every day. Thus, it brings me great sadness to see and hear people juxtapose what is sacred against what is science. The implication is one wrong, and one is right. The bias is both disrespectful of the Hawaiian people and purposeful manipulation of what science means. It is a false dichotomy.
For years I have searched for information about natural places in the Western World we westerners regard as sacred. To date, I have found only one. It is a forest in the Midwest where the founder of the Mormon Church received a revelation. Yes, there are a significant number of churches and other human-made religious icons revered as sacred. I can find no valley, river, or mountain in the North or South America or Europe regarded by the westerners as sacred.
In Native America from Alaska to the tip of South America, there are thousands of natural places regarded as sacred by the indigenous peoples. From the first days of colonial beginnings, indigenous peoples and their sacred lands were denigrated, rejected, and destroyed by the people and governments of the colonies. In effect, they said, my culture is right; yours is primitive, unholy, and wrong.
Japan, in many respects, is more technologically advanced than the USA and yet their Shinto traditions are revered. The mere mention of building a massive telescope on top of Mt. Fuji is unfathomable. Sacred places and technology have their appropriate places. They have a cultural tradition ethic not commonly found in Western Society.
My Hawaiian Sister Puna Kihoi has taught me the meaning of Kapu Aloha; to act only from love, kindness, and empathy. This is the ethic of the protectors, the Kia‘i and is amazingly noble given the history of sedition toward this sovereign nation.  However, I remain somewhat wary of the telescope’s leaders. They declare unequivocally that there is no military connection to the project.  During my research on the beginnings of the telescope proposal, it is troubling to find the US Department of Defense funds the Lincoln Laboratory. The lab is an exclusive military R and D facility at MIT. Our tax money intended for space security and warfare, funds some of the critical work on the "adapted optics" imaging systems for the TMT.[5] Moreover, Lincoln Labs is collaborating with the scientists at Keck. There is a military connection on the Mauna. Detailed information is inaccessible and probably classified. We can only hope that "national security" will not be used as an excuse to lock Mauna Kea away.
Many people, including our Mayor, are shocked to learn as a scientist I do not support the TMT. People express surprise when I recognize the sacredness of Mauna Kea and do not approve of any development on the mountain. They seem to be saying I cannot be a scientist and believe in sacred lands too.  Yes, I find astronomy and astrophysics an interesting curiosity. Rather we should spend the money on understanding our planet, one that is very sick and needs much restoration from the Western ethic and deeds of exploitation.
Hawai‘i is my home; Hawaiian is my adopted culture. I have the honor to be hānai (adopted).  I have three sisters, that are friends, and mentors.  They enrich my understanding of what is sacred. In my scientist being, there is much room and Aloha that honors, respects, and cherishes what is sacred and pono.
For me, it is not about a big telescope versus the Hawaiians. It is about a centuries-old Western Culture that is too narcissistic and parochial to open its heart and mind to people other than themselves. Someday they will learn Kapu Aloha.
I stand with my brothers and sisters. ‘Onipa‘a!


References
[1] HUMAN INOCULATION EXPERIMENTS IN HAWAII INCLUDING NOTES ON THOSE OF ARNING AND OF FITCH M. Mouritz, Honolulu Star Bulletin Press 1916. http://ila.ilsl.br/pdfs/v19n2a11.pdf
[2] Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment https://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/timeline.htm


Tuesday, May 29, 2018

Dying for Freedom?

Sadness For Disingenuous Memorial Days

Dr. RH Bennett

In the brainwashing ritual of a Big Mac slogan, we are ever-present to the mantra of Memorial Day jingles.

·      They died to keep us free.
·      Freedom is not free.
·      Our fighting men bring freedom to the world.

 Some may pause for a half-second to wonder who are the nameless soldiers who died, and I wonder if I know any of them?  Then they immediately move on to the next smartphone post.

 You see we have sanitized war. We no longer look at the caskets and names every night on the news as we did during Viet Nam.  Today, we don't respect and honor the fallen. In fact, we keep it hidden, more effectively than scantily clothed breasts on the TV.

Honoring these sons, daughters, and spouses means we would bust our butts to make sure that the soldiers who risk death, are not put in harm's way for anything other than our true defense.

Do we ever stop and carefully ponder our mindless slogans and this war sanitation? It is doubtful, as it is far too painful.   We would have to realize the death could be mine.   We rationalize, hey they volunteered.   I am not responsible, the ego cries.  In no way am I even indirectly responsible.  I have no control over what the USA does!

My friends died in Viet Nam.  Not a one volunteered to save South East Asia from the “Advancing Red Menace” or to keep the USA safe from Communism, God forbid.   They were forced to become Centurions; it was called the Draft.  And like the Roman Centurions they fought well because like all wars, you kill or be killed.   It was not noble.  This is war and the way it was in Viet Nam, and the other wars decades before my high school buddies got shipped out to “Nam” by the JFK, LBJ or RMN meat grinder express.

My friends got a brief indoctrination on how to kill to get on the line and start giving General Westmoreland his cherished body counts.  This Four Star General thought he could wear out the North by fatal attrition.  A student of French History he was not.

My buddies fought to stop the enemy from killing them.   Nowhere in the meat grinder of jungle war was there one shred of a noble quest for freedom.  It is from this place on constant terror that US hearts perpetuated the horrors of the My Lai Massacre.  The troops were as they are today an armed and deadly brotherhood dedicated to each other with a single purpose, crazed survival, and rightfully so.

“If the war was unnecessary, then “They died for our freedom” can’t be a true statement”.  Matt Hershberger

Then along comes the Axis of Evil via the Bush Doctrine.  Iran had weapons of mass destruction lie and the deceptions of September 11th, mobilized a make-believe war on terror.  Again boys of my son's age volunteered this time for a noble and false cause. A cause that was the biggest fraud ever perpetrated in the name of freedom.  Rumsfeld said of the war, it would be, “Five days or five weeks or five months, but it certainly isn't going to last any longer than that." The war and its leaders ignorantly and arrogantly created a Jihad of terror that persists to this day.

Young men and women became the targets of hatred as the most powerful country in the world destroyed sovereign people and nations.  The US has been warring on governments in the Middle East, and elsewhere since the end of  WWI.   It has nothing to do with advancing freedom and democracy and everything to do with resources and money.

If war is one of the least effective ways to assure freedom, then “They died for our freedom” should not be a source of national pride.

The centurions of that war once again fought not to spread democracy or protect freedom but to stay alive.   That survival fight evoked such evil in the hearts of good men and women that PDST and suicides continue to extract an ungodly human price to this day. We must point to the hubris of egomaniacal leaders of the dearth of Cheney, Wolfowitz, Bolton, and Rumsfeld to mention a few.  Take heed on this Memorial Day, Bolton has his hand on the trigger once again.  His aim, blessed by the Saudiʻs, is Iran.  History is poised to repeat.

If the war was contrived for financial reasons, then “They died for our freedom” can’t be a true statement.

I am not a religious at all, but my belief the sacredness of all human life and the broken bonds of morality slash at my heart with every story of life and liberty and happiness lost for the acts of violence cloaked and sanitized as the war on terror.  To the innocent people whose lands we invaded, bombed and occupied we are the terrorists.  Like the Minute Men of the Revolutionary War, the people fought in any way they could.  These same innocents live in a crossfire of an Islamic civil war we promote even still.

Memorial Day is important but only if we are willing to do more than jargonistic thinking.  Saying they died for our freedom, is repugnantly self-serving. It is an unprincipled attempt to justify to oneʻs soul that a soldiers death has a purpose. It is to dodge the moral responsibility of personally sanctioned deaths.

Freedom has never been granted at the end of a gun, especially when the weapons and men and women holding them are merely centurions protecting the interests of the global elite.   Let this Memorial Day bring pause to jingle thinking and pray we chose to cease sending young men and women to die for national interests, under the guise of protecting our so-called freedom. 

If the war was contrived in the name of  God, then “They died for our freedom” can’t be a true statement.

Why do people have to die in a war for our freedom?  It is simple, Freedom in this context is a ruse.


Tuesday, May 8, 2018

You are an Atheist

OK, Call me an Atheist

Well, I am an atheist like Donald Trump is a man of faith!   The point to be made is labels are excuses for thinking and reasons for dehumanizing.  But in the common defense, people in some organized religions are told,  "Don't think we will do the thinking for you".   The discussion is stifled even before it begins. In other words, labels are officially promoted or at least tacitly approved.

Intrinsic in the label, atheist are concepts like heathen, godless, inhuman,  amoral. irreverent and even demonic.  Given that list, anyone that does not profess to a faith in a supreme being that is omnipresent, omnipotent and omniscient will most certainly "roast in hell for all eternity".

Letʻs look at the prejudice intrinsic in the label atheist.

According to the Vancouver Sun, University of British Columbia researchers conducted a total of six experiments on 350 Americans and 420 UBC students, of varying religions (67% of the Americans were Christian). In one experiment, they presented participants with the story of an "archetypal freerider" who cheats and steals a lot, and asked what group they thought that person might belong to. Participants were more likely to categorize the person as an atheist than as a Christian, Jew, Muslim, gay person, or feminist (some of the groups were chosen because they were "often described as threatening to majority religious values and morality"). Only rapists fared as poorly — participants were about as likely to put the "freerider" in this group. According to the study, "People did not significantly differentiate atheists from rapists."
https://jezebel.com/5864303/people-think-atheists-are-just-as-bad-as-rapists-christ

People did not differentiate atheists from rapists; that is a pretty radical view.   It implies that religious people are morally superior.   The headlines these days about sexual abuse, church fraud, the homosexual hypocrisy of a pastor,  Nazi Christians and church members profiting from pornography and prostitution in the hotels they own does not alter the belief at all.

Tom Jacobs wrote in the Pacific Standard 2014. 
It’s an important distinction, in that atheists can also form communities founded on ethical principles (humanism being a prominent example). But so long as people are convinced there is no good without God, atheists fighting for public acceptance face a struggle of Biblical proportions.
So we find ourselves trapped in a religious belief that says there is no good without God.  This is no doubt a common belief today but to which contemporary god are they referring?
Noteworthy Atheists
Hank Pellissier wrote,  Atheists have no faith, no expectation of benefit from a deity. So, atheists are probably selfish, right? Pitiless, parsimonious. Totally stingy misers, not passing a penny off to the poor…correct?
WRONG! Atheists, non-believers, secular humanists, skeptics—the whole gamut of the godless have emerged in recent years as inarguably the most generous benefactors on the globe. That’s right. Hordes of heretics are the world’s biggest damned philanthropists. Both individually and in groups, heathen infidels are topping the fundraising charts.
First, the facts. 
The current most charitable individuals in the United States, based on “Estimated Lifetime Giving,” are:
1) Warren Buffett (atheist, donated $40.785 billion to “health, education, humanitarian causes”)
2) Bill & Melinda Gates (atheists, donated $27.602 billion to “global health and development, education”)
3) George Soros (atheist, donated $6.936 billion to “open and democratic societies”)
A comprehensive list of important religious skeptics would include Thomas Paine, Clarence Darrow, Susan B. Anthony, Abraham Lincoln, W.E.B. Du Bois, Margaret Sanger, Langston Hughes, Eugene Debs, Thomas Edison, Kurt Vonnegut, Pete Stark, and numerous others. David Niose https://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-niose/great-nonbelievers-atheists-history_b_1677760.html

My Brand of Atheism.

As a young boy sitting on a desert ridge overlooking vast vast lands of the Anza Borrego State Park,  I was struck by the grandeur and symmetry of the place. This desert ecosystem could seem barren and lifeless, yet to me, it was teaming with life, complexity, and wonder.   There just had to be a creator, it was far too beautiful to happen by chance alone, my young mind pondered.  This same feeling arose one morning as I sat quietly meditating on the magnificence of Mt. Whitney as viewed from the high desert eastern side.
In my early teen years, I found myself identifying with kids from a church camp experience and followed them to church and getting baptized. The months later the spiritual disenchantment grew and I had to leave the hypocrisy of the Sunday- Good People.

Now a college student I was a secular as they come with moments of spiritual connectedness like assisting the birth of my grandfather's horse.   And so it went for decades.   I knew there was a creative force maybe it is a creator but certainly not one in my image.  "Creative Force" seemed to fit fine but even then most would have called me an atheist.

A few more decades pass  I am now the equivalent of a full professor and deeply engaged in science and the challenges that society faces.   I am a scientist but one that did not believe like some.  A colleague scientist told me once, "If we can't measure it does not exist".   Wow, really?  How do you measure love I asked?

As a biological scientist with a minor in chemistry, that happened by accident,  I would often enjoy the musings of Dr. Carl Sagan.  He was an atheist but with an astronomic reverence.   Then one day, I got my version of a Grand Unification Theory, one Einstein labored on for years.   I saw at the moment of the Big Bang all matter was created.   All carbon, sulfur, iron, nitrogen phosphorus etc came into existence.   Each of these elements has physical and chemical properties intrinsic to their molecular size and weight.   Then over billions of years, the cosmic dust stirred, exploded, imploded spun, and settled.  The rain came to one planet and the cosmic soup went into solution and walla life began.

That majestic desert landscape like all landscapes and oceans are a product of that soup.  The creative force I felt so many times played its hand at the big bang and the elements set on a path that created life and my ability to sit here and write this.
I sit in awe of that force.    So why pray tell are we quibbling about my belief in God.  I simply spell it differently.   No label fits this timeless majesty.

















Gervais, Will M., et al. "Global evidence of extreme intuitive moral prejudice against atheists." Nature Human Behaviour1.8 (2017): s41562-017.

  A Prayer for Our Veterans Unlike Trump,  I have great empathy and compassion for the unselfish men and women that have volunteered for the...